Gayatri Mantra Only for Men? - Updated

This is one of those posts that google "lost" last week. They recovered  2 out of 3 so far, and I am grateful.  However, the third one -still missing- was my review of David Keil's Yoga Anatomy into which I had put hours of work.  I hope they recover it and I can get it back up soon.

In the meantime, perhaps is good to bring this post updated, as some people got involved in the comments and it made it more interesting.

This was my original question:

Someone identified as anonymous commented yesterday in the 32 Unusual Ways to Attract Abundance into Our Lives and said that the Gayatri Mantra is traditionally not to be recited by women.

He posted the comment in all fairness and in a sweet manner and said:

Traditionally Gayatri mantra is not for women. And if done, this is the only one that requires the person to take shower before and wear clean, washed clothes and also at sun rise, noon, sun set. Any other chant can be performed any time because one can think of god any given time. Just something I know coming from a very traditional background and wanted to share.

My knowledge of this mantra, I admit, is limited as I only know what I read in books I bought in India, and what I can piece together. So I replied to him and asked whether this was written in scriptures or where did he hear that. But I wonder...

Then came some answers:

EcoYogini pointed us out to the wikki definition which states that in Induism the mantra is traditionally sang by males brahmins - but modern hindu reform movements have spread the practice to include women and all casts.

Then Anja, a woman who has lived in India all her life gave a more personal accoun which you can read in full in the comments of this post, of note to me was where she said:

".... A hindu brahmin male, at a young age is initiated into the study of vedas... An important part of this ceremony is where the father of the boy recites the gayatri mantra in the boy's ear several times...


... As a young girl, when I went to the upanyam of a cousin and asked my mom to tell me the secret mantra that was being recited in my cousin's ear, I was told that women should not chant the mantra even if they know it. Yoga asanas and especially the Surya Namaskara was also traditionally practised only by brahmin males. Though this privilege is not explicitly mentioned in any of the scriptures as far as I know."


She concludes that the upper casts of India wanted to hold on to the power brought about by the mantra and perhaps this is the reason why it was not shared.  I guess that makes sense... God bless them for trying.

Now the secret is out, and the Gayatri Mantra is widely available, here is a YouTube version I love.

Perhaps the only thing we lack now is personal experience of its power.  May we all benefit!




Check these out:





16 comments:

  1. Hey Claudia,
    I don't live in India (obviously!), but I have once heard an Indian friend tell me the same thing. But it was a very casual conversation, and it never occurred to me to ask him why.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I don't know the precise answer to this question, but I would remind everyone that many, many things have not "traditionally" been done by women. Voting, owning property and speaking in places of worship come to mind. This does not mean we should not do these things. Only that it took a while for society to become enlightened enough to find them acceptable.

    Looking forward to hearing the history behind this mantra prohibition. In the meantime, chant on, dear yogis!

    Monette
    www.SophiaRisingYoga.com

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi Nobel, thanks for telling me, I wonder if it is a secret, only spoken among men... hee hee

    Monette, I hear you my friend, I love the mantra and it has done some pretty amazing things in my life, not only that I believe something like 99.5 % of it is sang to the divine mother, so it cannot be leaving women out...then again, I wonder about the story behind I am really curious... so I do not want to scare anyone...

    ReplyDelete
  4. Oh, and Monette has also reminded me that yoga is one of those things that were not traditionally done by women; obviously, this doesn't mean that women shouldn't do yoga...

    ReplyDelete
  5. Kind of ironic right? now more women than men practice it... as far as we know... very interesting

    ReplyDelete
  6. yoga used to be only for men too

    ReplyDelete
  7. yeah, that is right... recent change, and it seems we took it to heart!

    ReplyDelete
  8. ah!...so that's why I couldn't comment on the review of David's Dvd's. The post appeared in my google reader, but then seemed not to exist when I tried to open it...all is explained. :)

    I wanted to let you know I sent the review on to David from my google reader...he likes feedback and is always collecting new ideas to make anatomy more accessible to everyone...he said thank you. :)

    ReplyDelete
  9. Christine, that is great, thank you, I am glad you did :-)

    and by the way would you happen to have that email? if you did then I can post it again? if you do have it would you email me at baticlau@gmail.com? I doubt it may be in reader but if you mailed it perhaps in sent items?

    I am glad he got a chance to see it, I found it very helpful! I was so disappointed when google took it away!

    ReplyDelete
  10. Good news...it's still in my google reader. I just emailed it to you.
    :)

    ReplyDelete
  11. Fascinating post! I will have to ask my teacher what his thoughts are about women chanting the Gayatri.
    I am not at all an expert but I have done a 30 day Gayatri mantra sadhana. My experience was that the practice generated tons of energy. By the end of the 30 days I felt like the top of my head was going to blow off. I am very cautious now with this mantra. I didn't feel like I was able to use the energy productively but I am curious about trying to harness the energy and direct it. Still a work in progress.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Hi Yoga iwth Mirella, 30 years! wow, that sounds fascinating... I love the chant myself cannot imagine what 30 years of it would do...

    So glad you shared it, and if you do ask your teacher please let me know I would be curious

    ReplyDelete
  13. 30 days not years. LOL.
    My teacher strongly disagrees that only men should use the Gayatri
    Mantra. He didn't elaborate though.

    ReplyDelete
  14. oooops!!! wow sorry, quite an overstatement, no wonder my jaw dropped! guess have a lot on the mind, need to sing the mantra myself

    ReplyDelete
  15. Hi Claudia,
    I remember asking this question quite often growing up. We studied in a school where we girls were allowed to say the Gayatri Mantra. However, I have heard from many that the reason why women were told not to say was that it had a lot of powerful energy and that it could negatively affect a woman's womb. I cannot however, vouch for this information.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Hello Arwenevenstar, liked your "about me" page :-) that is very interesting... sounds a little, and i could be wrong, like a story to keep women in fear of it...

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.